Corante Media Hub OUR PUBLICATIONS:

Corante Media Hub

Feb

28

Morning Roundup: Pitfalls of Unfiltered Citizen Journalism; Blogs as News Sound-bytes; Journalism and Blogging Share a Challenge

Posted by Tish Grier

Steve Yelvingtion on recent criticism of unfiltered citizen journalism portal YourHub.com: "I \think asking members of the community to write traditionally structured news stories, and then presenting those stories unfiltered as if they are newspaper-style journalism, is a mistake... That's why I have grown to prefer using the terms 'participatory] and 'conversational.' A site that is built around strong community interaction will develop its own methods of fixing this problem -- quickly. An active community filters itself through a process of criticism and response."

Evelyn Rodriguez, who chronicled her ordeal experiencing and recovering from the tsunami of late 2004, shares a conversation she had with a Reuters reporter about the use of blogs as a vehicle for telling "microstories": "'This story [tsunami recovery and rehab] is like trying to photograph the Grand Canyon,' I told him. 'It's more nuanced and complex than the aftermath.' I lamented no photograph can possibly do the Grand Canyon justice. No telephoto lens, no panoramic lens, no IMAX film. It all falls short of the 360 degree experience in the flesh. 'If it's like the Grand Canyon, then every shot will be a great one,' Ed rejoined... And bingo! there he had it. The closest 'strategy' I've come up with for sharing the avalanche (or dare I call it a tsunami) of material I have is to simply write keep writing vignettes. Dozens, hundreds if need be."

Tom Abate, who will be speaking at the New Communications Forum later this week, considers the shared challenge for journalists and bloggers in previewing his remarks: "I will suggest that the differences between journalists and bloggers are not so important as thinking about how to accomplish the higher mission of journalism. In an advertising-supported environment how does any media undertake the unpopular and difficult issues? I'll have some thoughts about how the people we now call bloggers should rename themselves something along the lines of personal publishers -- and add some thoughts about how these small businesses can create the systems that will enable them to make a living -- and a difference."

COMMENTS

1. Evelyn Rodriguez on February 28, 2006 01:57 PM writes...

I really like Tom's comments about the greater mission of journalism. Bloggers can get all goo goo eyed (or is that Google-eyed) about citj and the tsunami, Katrina and London bombings. The mainstream media is ALREADY all over these stories. What I care about is if we can create and sustain conversations in stories and in areas MSM ignores and overlooks.

The headline is misleading - it's NOT blogs as news sound-bytes at all. We're trying to get away from sound-bytes as they don't capture the myriad angles of reality. Brian Oberkirch, who is also on Disasters & New Citizen Journalism panel with me at NewCommForum said (and I agree): I said I didn't have a sound byte - i tooo have zillion stories & vignettes...which, as a whole, are much truer than whatever 2:30 min. standup they'll do on the NBC news tonight.

Permalink to Comment

POST A COMMENT




Remember Me?